I saw this this morning:
China warned the United States on Thursday against “groundless smear attacks” against Chinese products and said it was working responsibly to address concerns over a spate of recent food safety scares.
“The Chinese Government has not turned a blind eye or tried to cover up. We have taken this matter very seriously, acted responsibly and immediately adopted forceful measures,” said a statement by China’s embassy in Washington.
“Blowing up, complicating or politicizing a problem are irresponsible actions and do not help in its solution,” the Chinese mission said in a rare policy pronouncement.
“It is even more unacceptable for some to launch groundless smear attacks on China at the excuse of food and drug safety problems,” it said.
Echoing the Beijing government’s complaints about U.S. media reports, the embassy said food safety concerns were not unique to China, 99.2 percent of whose food exports to the United States in 2006 met quality standards.
Problematic U.S. imports from China — including toxic ingredients mixed into pet food and recalls of toy trains and toothpaste — were isolated cases and “hardly avoidable” amid huge and rapidly growing bilateral trade, the statement said.
“It is unfair and irresponsible for the U.S. media to single China out, play up China’s food safety problems and mislead the U.S. consumer,” it added.
This statement comes on the heels of another story about cardboard being used to make steamed buns. I noticed that a certain thin-skinned bagua and xingyi teacher from south-west Canada was really ticked off by us foreigners discussing this on the Cheng Shi Bagua Yahoo list. He claimed that people are just “China bashing.”
And that’s where we are with this stuff: if you see that China obviously has a big problem with this stuff, then you’re racist and China-bashing. Reporting it is a “smear campaign.”
So, naturally, the reporter that broke this story is in hot water and has likely been forced to recant:
“Zi had provided all the cardboard and asked the vendor to soak it. It’s all cheating,” the paper quoted a government notice as saying.
Beijing TV had apologized for failing to check the report’s authenticity and said it would make efforts to improve staff ethics, the paper added.
China is reeling from a series of tainted food and drug scandals that have sparked criticism at home and abroad.
The deaths of patients in Panama from mislabeled drug ingredients from China, deadly toxins in pet food exported to the United States and food laced with hazardous antibiotics and chemicals have raised fears about the safety of China’s surging exports.
… and lead in the paint of Thomas the Train toys, rat poison in the breakfast ingredients of a local stand that killed 120 people, etc., etc., etc. But hey, no problem here. Just a bunch of “isolated incidents.”
Anyone that reports this stuff will get canned, just like this reporter in the story above. Is the story fake as the government so naturally claims (can’t let those exports get hurt) or is the reporter trying to make a name for himself at others expense? Who can tell when the government controls the “truth”?
We’ve had problems like this in Taiwan, so I know that China is much, much worse. A few years back, some dirtbags tried to pass off used industrial machine oil as cooking oil and killed a few people before they got caught. But the frequency with which this stuff happens in China is just unreal. We get reports constantly about goods from China being poisonous or just unhealthy.
We once bought a set of toy trucks for my boy from China, and when we opened the package, we saw that they were dirty and damaged. My wife soaked them in detergent before she gave them to our son. No more stuff from China for him.
So don’t buy into this BS about China bashing and being racist. Watch what you buy from China.











4 responses so far ↓
1 Edward // Jul 21, 2007 at 12:01 pm
Well - in China we have “face” (mian) and in Japan we have “harmony” (wa)… both are really just beautified excuses. The end product is that people just don’t talk about embarassing things to each other; they rather just hope that by ignoring them, they will go away.
In Japan, for example, if I talk to someone about racism here, Ianfu (comfort women), Burakumin (complicated subject), etc. - people just sort of shift their toes and look uncomfortable, as if they were just reminded of something they didn’t want to remember. This of course stunts anything in the way of progress here - because they like to pretend that the problems existing here do not exist. The only problems they point out are the “external” problems - i.e. foreigners are evil, a bad egg here and there, etc.
Americans are a bit different in that they LIKE to talk about pervading problems like racism, sexism, or almost anything else - I think this is also one reason why progress seems to be faster than other places.
To fix a problem - people first have to recognize it.
Basically, Japan and Korea have similar problems with China here. (And also, it is rather obvious that we don’t have China/Chinese things, since we are spending so much time trying to learn Chinese martial arts! If anything, we have a stronger interest in China than usual.)
2 jonathan liljeblad // Jul 21, 2007 at 9:49 pm
yeah, i noticed the same cultural issues you did.
i know Chinese culture still feels the sting of intimidation and conflict with Western imperial powers from the late 19th and early 20th centuries, and that is probably why they bristle so much at accusations from the West (because it recalls the Western condescension against Asia from those times).
but i think by doing so, they lose the point of a lot of modern Western complaints–particularly regarding corruption and cheating: these are serious problems, and public health is something very important. poisonous food products, substandard manufactured goods, toxic materials…these are things that NOBODY should want.
do these problems exist in the West? of course, but the government doesn’t take discussion of them as a personal or racist attack, and instead uses them as motivation to fix the problems.
3 Dojo Rat // Jul 21, 2007 at 10:52 pm
I saw where China executed their head of the Food and Drug Administration. I thought that was a little extreme, but later realized that they might have done it to silence him - perhaps he would have talked about how extensive the problem is.
Here in the U.S. the government won’t allow individual beef cattle producers test every cow for mad cow disease. Some want to so they can get more money for their beef in Japan, etc. - They won’t let them because there is a lot more mad cow out there than people would like to think. Same with toxins in comercial fertilizers and much more…
D.R.
4 jonathan liljeblad // Jul 21, 2007 at 11:31 pm
i don’t know if this link is going to work (it’s from today’s LA Times opinion section), but i think you’d enjoy reading it. if it doesn’t work, let me know and i’ll see if i can get the text:
http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/la-oe-august20jul20,0,1499357.story?coll=la-opinion-rightrail
Leave a Comment